
Biography
Peter Joseph "PJ" Polaco is an American professional wrestler, best known for his appearances with Extreme Championship Wrestling (ECW) and WWE under the ring name Justin Credible. He is also known for his earlier stint with WWE under the ring name Aldo Montoya. In WWF/WWE, he was an eight-time WWF/E Hardcore Champion. In ECW, he was a one-time ECW World Heavyweight Champion and a two-time ECW World Tag Team Champion with Lance Storm as the Impact Players. Polaco returned to the independent circuit in 2007 using the name "Justin Time". He wrestled for the Pro Wrestling Syndicate promotion, along with fellow original ECW wrestlers Sabu, Danny Doring and Julio Dinero, as well as making appearances for the Insane Clown Posse owned Juggalo Championship Wrestling. On March 29, 2009 he became the Big Time Wrestling Champion, defeating "Hurricane" John Walters with Ric Flair as special guest referee, but Credible was stripped of the title in August of the same year. Justin is also the topic of an upcoming documentary The Price of Fame which also includes Ted DiBiase and Sean Waltman. He was inducted into the New England Pro Wrestling Hall of Fame on July 12, 2009. On August 8, 2010, Polaco returned to TNA to take part in the ECW-themed pay-per-view Hardcore Justice where he performed as P.J. Polaco due to the WWE owning the rights to the Justin Credible name; Polaco was defeated by Stevie Richards. Afterwards, he was assaulted by former rival The Sandman with a Singapore cane. On January 14, 2012, Credible returned to the former ECW Arena, when he was defeated by Sabu at an Evolve event in the venue's final professional wrestling match. On April 28, 2012, Polaco was scheduled to wrestle on Shane Douglas' Extreme Reunion show, but was removed from the card, as well as the building after being found "slumped over, passed out asleep" in a chair. While he begged management to be let back on the show, they denied his request and kicked him out a second time. On August 8, 2012, Chikara announced that Polaco, returning to his Aldo Montoya character, would be making his debut for the promotion in the following month's 2012 King of Trios tournament, where he would team with the 1-2-3 Kid and Tatanka as "Team WWF". In their first round match on September 14, Team WWF was defeated by The Extreme Trio (Jerry Lynn, Tommy Dreamer and Too Cold Scorpio). Polaco retired on November 20, 2015, after facing long-time rival Tommy Dreamer at a Pro Wrestling Syndicate event. Credible faced Matt Tremont in a winning effort at CZW show in August 2016. In March 2017, he returned to wrestling, and teamed with The Sandman & New Jack in a winning effort at ECPW show. Polaco is of Portuguese ancestry. His parents emigrated to the United States from Portugal three years before he was born. He speaks Portuguese fluently. Peter and his wife Jill Marie Polaco née Jurecki were married on June 4, 1997. They have a son Nicholas (born April 2000).
Acted in 78
2020s
- 2022
Witch Trials
Peter
- 2021
A Little Dream
Baseball Coach · 1 episode
- 2020
Talk N' Shop A Mania 2
Justin Credible
2010s
- 2019
- 2015
ECW - Unreleased Vol. 3
Justin Credible
- 2014
Timeline: The History of ECW – 2000 – As Told By Justin Credible
Justin Credible
WWE Rivalries
TV
- 2013
ECW - Unreleased Vol. 2
Justin Credible
Barbed Wire City: The Unauthorized Story of Extreme Championship Wrestling
Movie
- 2012
ECW - Unreleased Vol. 1
Justin Credible
EVOLVE 10 - A Tribute To The Arena
Justin Credible
ROH: Ring of Hardcore
Justin Credible
- 2010
TNA Hardcore Justice 2010
P.J. Polaco
2000s
- 2007
Wrestling Society X
TV
- 2006
WWE Vengeance 2006
Justin Credible (Lumberjack)
WWE vs. ECW: Head to Head
Justin Credible
- 2005
TNA Genesis 2005
P.J. Polaco
Hardcore Homecoming: November Reign
Justin Credible
Hardcore Homecoming
Justin Credible
- 2004
ROH: At Our Best
Justin Credible
ROH: 2nd Anniversary
Justin Credible
ROH: Collision Course
Justin Credible
- 2003
ROH: Main Event Spectacles
Justin Credible
ROH: Tradition Continues
Justin Credible
MLW War Games
PJ Walker
ROH: Beating The Odds
Justin Credible
ROH: Death Before Dishonor
Justin Credible
ROH: Night of The Grudges
Justin Credible
- 2002
WWE Insurrextion 2002
Justin Credible
- 2001
WWE Survivor Series 2001
Justin Credible
WWE Rebellion 2001
Justin Credible (Dark Match)
WWE Judgment Day 2001
Justin Credible
WWE Insurrextion 2001
Justin Credible
WWE Backlash 2001
Justin Credible
ECW Deep Impact
Justin Credible
WWE WrestleMania X-Seven
Justin Credible (Sunday Night Heat)
ECW Guilty as Charged 2001
Movie
- 2000
ECW Holiday Hell 2000
Justin Credible
ECW Massacre on 34th Street
Justin Credible
ECW November to Remember 2000
Justin Credible
ECW Anarchy Rulz 2000
Justin Credible
ECW Heat Wave 2000
Justin Credible
ECW Hardcore Heaven 2000
Justin Credible
ECW Wrestlepalooza 2000
Justin Credible
ECW Living Dangerously 2000
Justin Credible
ECW Guilty as Charged 2000
Justin Credible
1990s
- 1999
ECW November to Remember 1999
Justin Credible
ECW Anarchy Rulz 1999
Justin Credible
ECW Heat Wave 1999
Justin Credible
ECW Hardcore Heaven 1999
Justin Credible
ECW CyberSlam 1999
Justin Credible
ECW Living Dangerously 1999
Justin Credible
ECW Crossing The Line 1999
Justin Credible
ECW House Party 1999
Justin Credible
ECW Guilty as Charged 1999
Justin Credible
- 1998
ECW November To Remember 1998
Justin Credible
ECW Heat Wave 1998
Justin Credible
ECW A Matter of Respect 1998
Justin Credible
ECW It Ain't Seinfeld
Justin Credible
ECW Wrestlepalooza 1998
Justin Credible
ECW Living Dangerously 1998
Justin Credible
ECW CyberSlam 1998
Justin Credible
ECW House Party 1998
Justin Credible
- 1997
ECW November to Remember 1997
Justin Credible
ECW As Good As It Gets
Justin Credible
- 1996
WWE Survivor Series 1996
Aldo Montoya (Free-for-All)
WWE Royal Rumble 1996
Aldo Montoya
- 1995
WWE Royal Rumble 1995
Aldo Montoya
- 1994
WWE March to WrestleMania X
P.J. Polaco
- 1993
No release date
ECW: Rob Van Dam vs Jerry Lynn
Justin Credible
Appearances9
2010s
- 2019
2000s
- 2007
- 2004
ROH: Generation Next
Himself
ROH: Reborn - Stage Two
Himself
ROH: Reborn - Stage One
Himself
- 2003
ROH: Empire State Showdown
Himself
ROH: Wrath of The Racket
Himself
1990s
- 1999
Beyond the Mat
Self
No release date
Credible
Self
Thanked in the credits1
2020s
- 2020
Massacre Manor
Thanks