Skip to content
balasaur

The Best Mystery Shows of All Time

Sherlock leads at 89, ahead of Batman: The Animated Series (89) and The Twilight Zone (89). 60 titles made the cut, ordered from highest Balasaur Score to lowest. The typical pick here scores 83, well above the catalog median of 66. The newest addition is IT: Welcome to Derry, released in October 2025. The score blends IMDb, Rotten Tomatoes, Metacritic, and TMDB ratings into one 0 to 100 number.

Scores run 89 down to 79. 28 of the 60 are from the 2010s. 19 of the 60 stream on Hulu.

60 titlesUpdated 2026-08-28Ranked by Balasaur Score

Seen a few of these? Track what you've watched and Balasaur learns your taste. It's free.

Start rating

Related collections

Mystery Shows on Netflix, Ranked 60Mystery Shows on Hulu, Ranked 60Mystery Shows on Peacock, Ranked 60